If you are currently in a space of deconstruction or faith transition, this time of year leading up to the holidays and extra time with family may have you feeling some anxiety about how to navigate this season. It may feel hard to imagine opting out of some family traditions that have held meaning for you your whole life (you've never missed a candlelight Christmas Eve service) AND it may also feel hard to imagine participating in the ways that you used to (saying grace at Thanksgiving would feel totally disingenuous).
This can all feel very confusing, especially if you feel like you're in the messy middle of the transition. As someone who does therapy for faith deconstruction in Denver I want you to know: there isn't a correct answer here. Participating isn't a betrayal of the work you've done, and opting out isn't a betrayal of the people you love. This post is about one very practical piece: what to do with holiday rituals you no longer fully believe in.
Better questions than "Should I?"
Asking what you "should" do tends to drag the old rulebook back into the room. These questions may be more helpful:
What would I be going for? Your grandma, the music, the tradition, a sense of belonging, guilt about not going, or fear of what happens if you don't? None of those are wrong reasons, it just helps to know what's motivating you.
What happens in my body when I picture walking in? A tight chest, a wave of nostalgia, a sense of crawling out of your skin, deep comfort or some confusing mix of it all. Your body can often communicate in ways your brain may have trouble forming words for.
What would make it doable? Driving yourself so you can leave early. Sitting near the aisle. Arriving after the sermon. Singing the carols you love and staying quiet through the ones that sting.
What does it cost to say yes, and what does it cost to say no? Both choices have a price. You get to decide which one you're willing to pay this year.
You can take part without fully buying in
Plenty of people bow their heads at grace because someone they love is praying, not because they agree with every word. Depending on your process, this may feel hypocritical or inauthentic. It may also feel like a demonstration of love or respect, and choosing connection on purpose is a form of integrity, too.
You can also participate in pieces. You might stand for the songs but skip the call and response. You might light a candle on Christmas Eve because it means something to you about hope, even if it doesn't mean what it used to. Some people find that the hymns they grew up with still move them. Others find any reminder of their religion of origin to be triggering. Both responses are understandable and either one can change over time.
You can create your own new traditions
Maybe this year just isn't the year to try to find a balance between your family's traditions and wishes for the holidays and your comfort and wellbeing. That's ok, too. It may be painful. There may be arguments and guilt trips if you tell your family you won't be home for the holidays. That will be difficult, and you can handle it.
What is exciting about this possibility is that you have the opportunity to create your own traditions and find new meaningful ways to celebrate the season. Maybe you get to attend your affirming church's Christmas services for the first time if you stay put rather than visiting family. Maybe you skip Christmas altogether and opt for celebrating the winter solstice. Maybe you host a Friendsgiving and spend quality time with people who know you and love you for who you are now.
If you're LGBTQ+
For many LGBTQ+ folks, the question isn't only "Do I believe this?" but also "Will I be welcome there? Will my partner be?" Your decision can account for that without apology. However much it matters to your dad or grandmother that the whole family is together on Thanksgiving, Christmas, or any other big day, you're allowed to weigh your own wellbeing as heavily as anyone else's comfort.
When your deconstruction isn't public knowledge
Maybe you haven't looped your family into your deconstruction process (and there are a lot of reasons why this might be the case). The holidays are likely to present situations for your family to notice something has shifted. You don't owe anyone a full theological explanation over pie. Something like "I'm skipping the service this year, but I'd love to come over for brunch" is a complete answer. If you're preparing for a bigger conversation, How to Tell Your Family You're Deconstructing walks through that in more detail.
How therapy can help
Therapy for faith transitions gives you room to sort out which beliefs are actually yours and which were handed to you that you're ready to drop. Recovering from religious harm often means relearning how to trust your own intuition, and that's something we can work on together. It might also look like untangling the guilt that shows up on Sundays, practicing what you want to say to your parents, or noticing what your body is telling you about certain spaces. When a specific memory still hits hard years later, some clients find that EMDR therapy helps that memory lose some of its charge.
Whatever you decide about this season, I hope it feels like your decision.
Let's talk
If you're in Denver or anywhere in Colorado and you're wrestling with what faith looks like for you now, I'd love to hear from you. I offer a free consultation call so you can ask any questions you have, we can cover the logistics like scheduling and fees, and we can both get a sense of whether working together feels like a good fit. There's no pressure and nothing you need to prepare. Schedule your free consultation whenever you're ready.
